Richard Fuller recently called an adjournment debate in the House of Commons on the Impact of the East West Rail Bedford to Cambridge business case on North Bedfordshire constituency. You can watch the full debate at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wr2nZT4KgJE&t=1229s
Summarising the debate, he said:
Sadly, the lessons of HS2 appear to have been ignored. Billions of pounds of public money are at stake.
The last published benefit-cost ratio for East West Rail was just 0.3, meaning that 70p is wasted for every pound invested, which represents extremely poor value for money. Under UK Treasury guidelines, a BCR below 1.0 is considered "poor".
Even with further adjustments, the figures remain deeply concerning.
Yet my constituents are still waiting for answers on the route, the costs, the environmental damage and the economic case.
I called a debate in the House of Commons to challenge the Government to publish the latest business case NOW. Taxpayers deserve transparency before more money is committed.
I asked whether the Government should reconsider the route as it would make more sense to create a hub station in Wixams, in light of the planned Universal Studios development which will bring millions of visitors a year, rather than going into the town of Bedford and then north through rural North Bedfordshire. That route is long, hilly and incredibly environmentally damaging, and must surely be much more expensive than any alternative.
I also asked whether East West Rail is being allowed to justify its business case by desperately taking credit for projects such as housing growth at Tempsford, which has been in the planning for a long time already.
Ultimately, I asked the Minister a simple question: if he were presented with a railway that would lose billions, offered the worst value for money of any railway built this century, had not carried a single passenger on its completed section for two years, and still had not decided how to power its trains, would he really give it the go-ahead?
An adjournment debate is a short debate of thirty minutes at the end of a sitting day in the UK House of Commons which allows an MP to raise a specific issue, often on a constituency matter, and receive a response from a government minister, with no vote taken at the end.
